A confidential informant (CI) is an individual who provides information to law enforcement about suspected criminal activity, usually in exchange for some form of consideration such as leniency, reduced charges, or other benefits. CIs play a significant role in many criminal investigations, including cases involving drugs, organized crime, fraud, and firearms.
Confidential informants are often able to go places where law enforcement can’t go and get criminals to speak more freely than they ever would around a police officer.
However, the information they provide is not always reliable. An experienced Oakland criminal defense lawyer can help dismantle a case based on information provided by a confidential informant.
The Role of a “Confidential Informant”
A confidential informant is someone who cooperates with police or prosecutors by sharing information that may help investigate or prosecute others.
Their identity is typically kept secret to protect their safety and preserve the integrity of ongoing investigations. Informants are often referred to by code names or numbers in police reports and court filings.
Law enforcement uses confidential informants because they can provide access to information that would otherwise be difficult or impossible to obtain. Informants may have insider knowledge of criminal activity, relationships with suspects, or access to locations and communications that police cannot easily penetrate on their own.
There are important distinctions between confidential informants and cooperating witnesses. A confidential informant usually provides information during the investigative stage, often without testifying in court.
In contrast, a cooperating witness typically testifies openly at trial or in court proceedings. Some informants eventually become cooperating witnesses, but many never do.
For a free legal consultation, call (510) 995-0000
Who Becomes a Confidential Informant?
Confidential informants come from many backgrounds. Some are people who were arrested or charged with a crime and agreed to cooperate in exchange for a potential benefit. Others may be individuals already involved in criminal activity, former associates of suspects, or even civilians who observed wrongdoing.
There is no single “type” of informant, which is why their credibility must always be carefully evaluated.
What Benefits Do Confidential Informants Receive?
The benefits for confidential informants vary widely and depend on the circumstances. Common benefits include:
- Reduced charges or sentences
- Dismissal of certain counts
- Favorable plea agreements
- Monetary compensation (in limited situations)
Importantly, these incentives can create motivation for informants to exaggerate or fabricate information, which is why informant testimony is often challenged in court.
Click to contact our criminal defense lawyers today
Are Confidential Informants Allowed to Commit Crimes?
In some cases, law enforcement may allow informants to engage in limited criminal activity as part of an investigation, such as participating in controlled drug buys. However, there are legal boundaries.
Informants are generally not allowed to initiate crimes, use excessive force, or commit serious violent acts. When these boundaries are crossed, it may raise serious legal issues that can affect a case.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
Does the Defense Have the Right to Know Who the Confidential Informant Is?
In many situations, the government attempts to keep an informant’s identity secret. However, if the informant’s identity or background is essential to the defense, such as when the informant was a key participant or the primary source of evidence, a judge may order disclosure. Defense attorneys often file motions seeking this information to ensure a fair trial.
How Reliable Is Information From a Confidential Informant?
Reliability varies. Some informants provide accurate, corroborated information, while others may have credibility problems due to criminal histories, substance abuse, or self-interest.
Courts often require law enforcement to corroborate informant tips with independent evidence, especially when those tips are used to justify searches, arrests, or warrants.
Can a Confidential Informant Be Used to Obtain a Search Warrant?
Yes. Information from a confidential informant can be used to support a search warrant, but only if it meets certain legal standards. Judges typically look at the informant’s reliability, past track record, and whether the information was independently verified. If these standards are not met, the warrant may be challenged.
Challenges to Cases Involving Confidential Informants
Entrapment occurs when law enforcement or their agents induce someone to commit a crime they were not otherwise predisposed to commit. If a confidential informant pressured, coerced, or manipulated a person into committing a crime, entrapment may be a viable defense. These cases are highly fact-specific and require careful legal analysis.
While informants are expected to provide truthful information, they are not always held to the same immediate accountability as sworn witnesses.
This is why defense attorneys closely scrutinize informant statements, agreements, and incentives. If an informant lies and that lie influences the case, it can significantly undermine the prosecution.
A case may be dismissed or evidence suppressed if:
- The informant acted unlawfully
- Law enforcement failed to properly supervise the informant
- The informant provided false information
- The defendant’s constitutional rights were violated
An experienced criminal defense attorney can evaluate whether informant misconduct affected the legality of the investigation.
When Your Case Involves a Confidential Informant
If you believe a confidential informant played a role in your arrest or charges, it is critical to speak with a knowledgeable criminal defense attorney as soon as possible. Do not attempt to investigate or confront anyone on your own. An attorney can protect your rights, assess the strength of the evidence, and determine the best defense strategy.
Confidential informants can make or break a criminal case. Their involvement raises complex legal questions about reliability, fairness, and constitutional protections.
Understanding how informants operate and how their credibility can be challenged is essential for anyone facing criminal charges.
Get Help From an Experienced Criminal Defense Lawyer Today
If you or a loved one is facing charges involving a confidential informant, the Silver Law Firm is prepared to help. Our team is committed to protecting your rights and ensuring that every aspect of the prosecution’s case is thoroughly examined. We offer strategic, compassionate legal representation designed to protect your rights and your future.
Contact us today by phone or through our online contact form to schedule a free and confidential consultation with a member of our legal team.
Call or text (510) 995-0000 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form
